Discover this beautifully maintained and truly unique multi-family property, offering exceptional versatility and charm on nearly an acre of landscaped grounds. Perfectly situated in the sought-after Baldwinsville School District, this property is ideal for the owner-occupant investor looking to offset their living expenses or build wealth through rental income.
This residence comprises two apartments plus a fully functional in-law suite addition currently rented as a third unit, providing strong income potential. The owner’s long-term stewardship is evident throughout, with thoughtful updates and quality additions that enhance both function and comfort.
Inside, you'll find generous living spaces with raised ceilings in the first-floor unit, creating an open, airy feel. The second-story addition expands the living area further, providing flexibility for tenants or extended family. Thermal pane comfort windows and doors ensure energy efficiency year-round, while many new appliances make move-in effortless for future occupants. A newer roof, low-maintenance vinyl siding, a new hot water tank, and an updated well pump with a modern water filtration system add to the peace of mind and ease of ownership.
Step outside to an outdoor oasis designed for both relaxation and entertaining. A back deck in the rear of the home, overlooks the peaceful grounds featuring a tranquil pond, a charming pergola, multiple storage sheds, and even a backyard lounge cabin.
This is more than just an income property—it's a rare chance to own a well-cared-for home with character, flexibility, and strong rental appeal in a fantastic school district. Don’t miss your opportunity to invest in quality living with built-in income potential.
9111 E Mud Lake Road, Lysander, NY 13027, is a 3 bedroom, 3 bathroom, 2318 sqft. Multi Family built in 1957.
This property is currently available for sale and was listed on Greater Rochester Association of REALTORS® on 7-16-2025.
The MLS# for this Multi Family is MLS# S1620430.
Display of MLS Data is usually deemed reliable but is NOT guaranteed accurate by the MLS. Buyers are responsible for verifying the accuracy of all information and should investigate the data themselves or retain appropriate professionals.
Copyright ©2026 Greater Rochester Association of REALTORS®