1050 Pennsylvania Ave, Southport, NY 14904

Once known as the Olthoff Funeral Home, this iconic property carries a legacy of service to the community and is now ready for a new chapter. With over 20,000 square feet of interior space, this expansive property offers exceptional potential for redevelopment or investment across a variety of commercial uses, including senior or assisted living opportunities. The primary building features multiple entrances and two main levels, offering incredible flexibility for future owners. The upper level includes a recreational room as well as the showroom for urns and caskets, providing versatile space that could be adapted for a variety of uses. The lower level features a chapel room for services, several clergy offices, and an elevator to help move large items throughout the building. Further down the hall, there is an unfinished area that could be completed for additional usable space. The property includes two living quarters: one upstairs, previously used by the funeral manager/director, and a second fully functional apartment that could serve for onsite management, residential use, or rental income. The site also includes a 3-car detached garage offering abundant storage or workspace potential, as well as a 2-car garage connected to Sycamore Street that previously served as the crematory, enhancing access and convenience. Beyond the main building, the property at 937–939 Sycamore Street is now vacant, providing additional opportunities for redevelopment or rental income. A large parking lot accommodates visitors and includes a leased secondary business that recently completed renovations and wishes to remain on-site. This business currently uses 8 designated parking spaces, providing immediate income stability for a new owner. Whether reimagined as a community center, office complex, event venue, mixed-use investment, or senior living facility, this property provides the space, structure, and flexibility to make nearly any vision a reality. Embrace the opportunity to write the next chapter for this remarkable property — a place once known for compassion, now ready to inspire new beginnings.