
- Buy
- Rent
- Commercial
- Find a REALTOR®
Find the perfect REALTOR® by searching here.
Search Rochester Real Estate Agents and Brokers
1 resultSort:
Susan MutherNY Licensed R.E. SalespersonKeller Williams Upstate NY PropertiesDelhi, NYLicense #10401290369
Direct
Cities
Zip Codes

3445 Winton Place, Suite 220 Rochester, NY 14623
© 2025 Greater Rochester Association of REALTORS®. All Rights Reserved.
Display of MLS Data is usually deemed reliable but is NOT guaranteed accurate by the MLS. Buyers are responsible for verifying the accuracy of all information and should investigate the data themselves or retain appropriate professionals.

Susan Muther
NY Licensed R.E. SalespersonKeller Williams Upstate NY Properties94 Main StDelhi, NY 13753License #10401290369Contact Susan
or
Direct
Office
Open HousesActive ListingsRecently Closed
No Open Houses
138 Church Street, Franklin, NY 13846

$33,000
238,709sqft
5.48acres
Commercial Business for Lease
138 Church Street, Franklin, NY 13846
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
464 Curtis Lane, Hamden, NY 13782

$339,000
3beds
2bath
1,352sqft
6.11acres
House for Sale
464 Curtis Lane, Hamden, NY 13782
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
6 Westridge Road, Otsego, NY 13326
$1,200,000
8beds
6bath
5,670sqft
2.97acres
House for Sale
6 Westridge Road, Otsego, NY 13326
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
Betty Brook Road, Kortright, NY 13842

Pending
$120,000
31.15acres
Agriculture Land for Sale
Betty Brook Road, Kortright, NY 13842
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
260 Southside Drive, Oneonta, NY 13820

PendingVirtual Tour
$335,000
3beds
2bath
1,750sqft
1.38acres
House for Sale
260 Southside Drive, Oneonta, NY 13820
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
153 Main Street, Delhi, NY 13753

$265,000
6beds
3bath
3,264sqft
0.08acres
Multi Family for Sale
153 Main Street, Delhi, NY 13753
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
265 Main Street, Delhi, NY 13753
$429,000
3beds
1bath
4,173sqft
1.4acres
Mixed Use for Sale
265 Main Street, Delhi, NY 13753
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
265 Main Street, Delhi, NY 13753
$429,000
3beds
1bath
4,173sqft
1.4acres
House for Sale
265 Main Street, Delhi, NY 13753
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
936 Potter Moutain Road, Conesville, NY 12076

PendingVirtual Tour
$470,000
4beds
3bath
3,800sqft
28.63acres
House for Sale
936 Potter Moutain Road, Conesville, NY 12076
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
0 Masonville Pond Cummings Road, Masonville, NY 13839

$300,000
36.67acres
Residential Land for Sale
0 Masonville Pond Cummings Road, Masonville, NY 13839
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
1144-1184 Hollister Hill Road, Delhi, NY 13753

Pending
$1,125,000
6beds
5bath
4,100sqft
158.4acres
House for Sale
1144-1184 Hollister Hill Road, Delhi, NY 13753
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
0 State Route 28, Andes, NY 13731

$670,000
83.7acres
Residential Land for Sale
0 State Route 28, Andes, NY 13731
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
0 County Highway 44, Sidney, NY 13849

PendingVirtual Tour
$65,000
32.95acres
Residential Land for Sale
0 County Highway 44, Sidney, NY 13849
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
4923 County Highway 36, Roxbury, NY 12421

Closed Apr 2, 2026
$480,000
2beds
2bath
1,720sqft
1.9acres
House for Sale
4923 County Highway 36, Roxbury, NY 12421
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
105 Stewart Road, Roxbury, NY 12421

Closed Mar 11, 2026
$1,200,000
4beds
3bath
5,412sqft
140acres
House for Sale
105 Stewart Road, Roxbury, NY 12421
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
207 Small Road, Middletown, NY 12455

Closed Feb 27, 2026
$720,000
3beds
3bath
2,602sqft
5.85acres
House for Sale
207 Small Road, Middletown, NY 12455
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
361 Warren Road, Meredith, NY 13753

Closed Feb 19, 2026
$845,000
5beds
2bath
1,344sqft
189.8acres
House for Sale
361 Warren Road, Meredith, NY 13753
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
70 Case Hill Road, Franklin, NY 13846

Closed Jan 16, 2026
$320,000
4beds
2bath
2,111sqft
1acres
House for Sale
70 Case Hill Road, Franklin, NY 13846
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
0 Woodland Hills Road, Andes, NY 13731

Closed Dec 23, 2025
$105,000
23.47acres
Cabin Land for Sale
0 Woodland Hills Road, Andes, NY 13731
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
1025 Gaffey Road, Harpersfield, NY 12167

Closed Dec 17, 2025
$525,000
3beds
2bath
2,535sqft
21.49acres
House for Sale
1025 Gaffey Road, Harpersfield, NY 12167
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
1399 Arbuckle Hollow Road, Delhi, NY 13752

Closed Dec 11, 2025
$615,000
3beds
2bath
3,192sqft
5acres
House for Sale
1399 Arbuckle Hollow Road, Delhi, NY 13752
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
11916 County Highway 23, Sidney, NY 13849

Closed Nov 12, 2025
$530,000
4beds
2bath
2,118sqft
36.02acres
House for Sale
11916 County Highway 23, Sidney, NY 13849
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
51 Saw Mill Road, Meredith, NY 13753

Closed Nov 10, 2025
$700,000
8beds
4bath
3,868sqft
1.82acres
House for Sale
51 Saw Mill Road, Meredith, NY 13753
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
4878 County Highway 18, Delhi, NY 13753

Closed Oct 16, 2025
$186,208
3beds
2bath
1,040sqft
4.3acres
Residential for Sale
4878 County Highway 18, Delhi, NY 13753
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
26 Saint John Street, Walton, NY 13856

Closed Oct 2, 2025
$225,000
3beds
1bath
1,688sqft
0.25acres
House for Sale
26 Saint John Street, Walton, NY 13856
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
1399 Arbuckle Hollow Road, Delhi, NY 13752

Closed Sep 19, 2025
$2,600
3beds
2bath
3,192sqft
5acres
House for Rent
1399 Arbuckle Hollow Road, Delhi, NY 13752
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
532 Wilbur Hill Road, Butternuts, NY 13849

Closed Sep 17, 2025
$350,000
3beds
2bath
2,049sqft
6.07acres
House for Sale
532 Wilbur Hill Road, Butternuts, NY 13849
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
279 Kersmanc Road, Decatur, NY 12197

Closed Sep 3, 2025
$33,000
5.21acres
Residential Land for Sale
279 Kersmanc Road, Decatur, NY 12197
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
4305 State Highway 80, Columbus, NY 13460

Closed Jul 30, 2025
$120,000
3beds
1bath
1,528sqft
0.61acres
House for Sale
4305 State Highway 80, Columbus, NY 13460
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
1092 Lewis Road, Meredith, NY 13757

Closed Jul 16, 2025
$22,500
–beds
1,532sqft
0.38acres
House for Sale
1092 Lewis Road, Meredith, NY 13757
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
51996 State Highway 10, Kortright, NY 13739

Closed Jul 14, 2025
$389,000
13,939sqft
0.45acres
Commercial Business for Sale
51996 State Highway 10, Kortright, NY 13739
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
0 NY Route 28, Bovina, NY 13731

Closed May 27, 2025
$131,500
41.66acres
Residential Land for Sale
0 NY Route 28, Bovina, NY 13731
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
28 Evergreen Lane, Windham, NY 12496

Closed May 2, 2025
$340,000
3beds
2bath
1,056sqft
2.7acres
House for Sale
28 Evergreen Lane, Windham, NY 12496
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
51 Delaware Avenue, Delhi, NY 13753

Closed Apr 28, 2025
$310,000
3beds
2bath
1,760sqft
0.52acres
House for Sale
51 Delaware Avenue, Delhi, NY 13753
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
3 Pearl Street E, Sidney, NY 13838

Closed Apr 14, 2025
$160,000
3beds
1bath
1,060sqft
0.63acres
House for Sale
3 Pearl Street E, Sidney, NY 13838
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
890 Dimmick Mountain Road, Roxbury, NY 12421

Closed Mar 31, 2025
$958,000
6beds
2bath
2,900sqft
11.7acres
House for Sale
890 Dimmick Mountain Road, Roxbury, NY 12421
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
26 Federal Hill Rd 2, Delhi, NY 13753

Closed Mar 19, 2025
$340,000
133.2acres
Agriculture Land for Sale
26 Federal Hill Rd 2, Delhi, NY 13753
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
0 Elk Creek Road, Meredith, NY 13806

Closed Mar 17, 2025
$142,000
40.1acres
Agriculture Land for Sale
0 Elk Creek Road, Meredith, NY 13806
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
108 Alimeda Road, Kortright, NY 13788

Closed Mar 14, 2025
$375,000
3beds
2bath
2,374sqft
5.1acres
House for Sale
108 Alimeda Road, Kortright, NY 13788
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
2359 Jackson Hill Road, Franklin, NY 13846

Closed Feb 27, 2025
$315,600
65.3acres
Agriculture Land for Sale
2359 Jackson Hill Road, Franklin, NY 13846
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
3415 County Highway 14, Franklin, NY 13775

Closed Jan 24, 2025
$400,000
4beds
1bath
1,799sqft
111.5acres
House for Sale
3415 County Highway 14, Franklin, NY 13775
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
2930 Blue School Road, Franklin, NY 13775

Closed Jan 17, 2025
$105,000
22.23acres
Residential Land for Sale
2930 Blue School Road, Franklin, NY 13775
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
0 Pumpkin Hollow Road, Davenport, NY 13750

Closed Dec 6, 2024
$174,000
86.9acres
Cabin Land for Sale
0 Pumpkin Hollow Road, Davenport, NY 13750
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
1135 Ridge Road, Hamden, NY 13782

Closed Nov 26, 2024
$290,000
3beds
1bath
1,450sqft
21.81acres
House for Sale
1135 Ridge Road, Hamden, NY 13782
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
624 Brownell Road, Kortright, NY 13739

Closed Nov 18, 2024
$663,000
4beds
1bath
2,033sqft
110.7acres
House for Sale
624 Brownell Road, Kortright, NY 13739
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
1278 Monroe Road, Meredith, NY 13753

Closed Nov 1, 2024
$300,000
1beds
1bath
684sqft
72acres
House for Sale
1278 Monroe Road, Meredith, NY 13753
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
0 Scotch Hill Ext Road, Kortright, NY 13739

Closed Oct 21, 2024
$48,800
5.5acres
Land for Sale
0 Scotch Hill Ext Road, Kortright, NY 13739
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
1408 Federal Hill Rd 2, Delhi, NY 13753

Closed Oct 3, 2024
$575,000
4beds
1bath
1,874sqft
74.4acres
House for Sale
1408 Federal Hill Rd 2, Delhi, NY 13753
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
364 Mostert Road, Delhi, NY 13753

Closed Sep 18, 2024
$900,000
3beds
3bath
1,800sqft
28.75acres
House for Sale
364 Mostert Road, Delhi, NY 13753
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
330 Middlemist Road, Delhi, NY 13753

Closed Aug 28, 2024
$1,200,000
4beds
2bath
3,257sqft
121.92acres
House for Sale
330 Middlemist Road, Delhi, NY 13753
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
0 Sweet Pea Drive, Franklin, NY 13753

Closed Aug 15, 2024
$75,000
10.83acres
Agriculture Land for Sale
0 Sweet Pea Drive, Franklin, NY 13753
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
83 Lake Street, Otsego, NY 13326

Closed Jul 31, 2024
$712,500
4beds
3bath
3,565sqft
6.34acres
House for Sale
83 Lake Street, Otsego, NY 13326
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
1399 Arbuckle Hollow Road, Delhi, NY 13752

Closed Jul 11, 2024
$525,000
3beds
2bath
3,192sqft
5acres
House for Sale
1399 Arbuckle Hollow Road, Delhi, NY 13752
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
40 Main Street, Delhi, NY 13753

Closed Jun 28, 2024
$260,000
8beds
3bath
3,368sqft
0.28acres
Multi Family for Sale
40 Main Street, Delhi, NY 13753
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
52 Chestnut Street, Otsego, NY 13326

Closed Jun 27, 2024
$710,000
6beds
4bath
3,271sqft
0.28acres
House for Sale
52 Chestnut Street, Otsego, NY 13326
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
1414 Fleming Road, Franklin, NY 13753

Closed Jun 21, 2024
$785,000
3beds
3bath
1,860sqft
81.21acres
House for Sale
1414 Fleming Road, Franklin, NY 13753
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
195 Fisk Hill Road, Unadilla, NY 13849

Closed May 22, 2024
$165,000
77.87acres
Agriculture Land for Sale
195 Fisk Hill Road, Unadilla, NY 13849
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
39 Franklin Street, Delhi, NY 13753

Closed May 6, 2024
$250,000
3beds
1bath
1,312sqft
0.38acres
House for Sale
39 Franklin Street, Delhi, NY 13753
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
677 Carman Road, Hamden, NY 13752

Closed Apr 30, 2024
$575,000
4beds
4bath
2,592sqft
5acres
House for Sale
677 Carman Road, Hamden, NY 13752
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
1 Howell Street, Walton, NY 13856

Closed Apr 22, 2024
$220,000
6beds
2bath
3,752sqft
0.25acres
Mixed Use for Sale
1 Howell Street, Walton, NY 13856
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
1473 W Highland Road, Stamford, NY 13788

Closed Apr 12, 2024
$92,500
6.48acres
Residential Land for Sale
1473 W Highland Road, Stamford, NY 13788
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
78 Mellis Brook Road, Colchester, NY 13755

Closed Apr 8, 2024
$184,000
2beds
1bath
1,205sqft
4acres
House for Sale
78 Mellis Brook Road, Colchester, NY 13755
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
1905 Monkey Run Road, Davenport, NY 13750

Closed Mar 29, 2024
$354,000
3beds
2bath
2,880sqft
10.84acres
House for Sale
1905 Monkey Run Road, Davenport, NY 13750
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
27905 State Highway 28, Andes, NY 13731

Closed Feb 14, 2024
$420,000
173,804sqft
3.99acres
Commercial Business for Sale
27905 State Highway 28, Andes, NY 13731
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
93 Kilkenny Street, Unadilla, NY 13849

Closed Feb 9, 2024
$335,000
4beds
3bath
2,432sqft
2.32acres
House for Sale
93 Kilkenny Street, Unadilla, NY 13849
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
27 Spruce Street, Oneonta, NY 13820

Closed Jan 30, 2024
$280,000
4beds
1bath
1,750sqft
0.18acres
House for Sale
27 Spruce Street, Oneonta, NY 13820
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
1295 Alameda Road, Kortright, NY 13788

Closed Jan 30, 2024
$462,000
3beds
2bath
1,450sqft
8.79acres
House for Sale
1295 Alameda Road, Kortright, NY 13788
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
544 Gesell Road, Meredith, NY 13757

Closed Jan 23, 2024
$333,000
3beds
2bath
1,713sqft
8.9acres
House for Sale
544 Gesell Road, Meredith, NY 13757
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
520 County Highway 12, Kortright, NY 13757

Closed Dec 21, 2023
$260,000
3beds
1bath
1,254sqft
11.86acres
House for Sale
520 County Highway 12, Kortright, NY 13757
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
0 Legg Road, Hunter, NY 12436

Closed Dec 15, 2023
$325,000
10.3acres
Residential Land for Sale
0 Legg Road, Hunter, NY 12436
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
575 Reed Road, Hamden, NY 13782

Closed Dec 15, 2023
$280,000
2beds
1bath
864sqft
5.55acres
House for Sale
575 Reed Road, Hamden, NY 13782
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
3853 Betty Brook Road, Kortright, NY 13842

Closed Dec 13, 2023
$195,000
3beds
2bath
1,400sqft
6.4acres
Residential for Sale
3853 Betty Brook Road, Kortright, NY 13842
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
881 Alameda Road, Kortright, NY 13788

Closed Nov 27, 2023
$412,000
4beds
1bath
1,548sqft
5.57acres
House for Sale
881 Alameda Road, Kortright, NY 13788
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
135 E View Road, Tompkins, NY 13839

Closed Nov 13, 2023
$214,298
4beds
2bath
1,527sqft
5.36acres
House for Sale
135 E View Road, Tompkins, NY 13839
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
1073 Irish Hill Road, Meredith, NY 13753

Closed Nov 6, 2023
$510,000
3beds
2bath
1,368sqft
29.86acres
House for Sale
1073 Irish Hill Road, Meredith, NY 13753
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
36654 State Highway 28, Middletown, NY 13731

Closed Oct 18, 2023
$175,000
3beds
2bath
2,107sqft
3.16acres
House for Sale
36654 State Highway 28, Middletown, NY 13731
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
350 Oak Road, Kortright, NY 13757

Closed Oct 4, 2023
$305,000
2beds
2bath
1,160sqft
5.01acres
House for Sale
350 Oak Road, Kortright, NY 13757
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
35 Main Street, Delhi, NY 13753

Closed Sep 21, 2023
$450,000
–beds
4,656sqft
0.95acres
Multi Family for Sale
35 Main Street, Delhi, NY 13753
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
0 Kersmanc Road, Decatur, NY 12197

Closed Sep 8, 2023
$27,000
5.21acres
Residential Land for Sale
0 Kersmanc Road, Decatur, NY 12197
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
627 West Platner Brook Road, Delhi, NY 13753

Closed Aug 25, 2023
$430,000
3beds
2bath
2,668sqft
34.7acres
House for Sale
627 West Platner Brook Road, Delhi, NY 13753
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
1242 County Road 35, Guilford, NY 13780

Closed Jul 24, 2023
$295,000
1beds
1bath
1,584sqft
1.09acres
House for Sale
1242 County Road 35, Guilford, NY 13780
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
152 Starr Road, Otego, NY 13825

Closed Jul 14, 2023
$530,000
3beds
3bath
1,716sqft
42.85acres
House for Sale
152 Starr Road, Otego, NY 13825
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
267 Hawkins Road, Sanford, NY 13754

Closed Jun 29, 2023
$425,000
3beds
2bath
2,052sqft
29.99acres
House for Sale
267 Hawkins Road, Sanford, NY 13754
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
3 Division Street, Delhi, NY 13753

Closed Jun 9, 2023
$177,200
–beds
2,130sqft
0.08acres
Multi Family for Sale
3 Division Street, Delhi, NY 13753
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
118 Trails End, Jefferson, NY 12093

Closed Jun 7, 2023
$615,000
4beds
2bath
1,866sqft
5.25acres
House for Sale
118 Trails End, Jefferson, NY 12093
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
1400 County Highway 48, Oneonta, NY 13820

Closed Apr 6, 2023
$725,000
5beds
4bath
5,242sqft
66.99acres
House for Sale
1400 County Highway 48, Oneonta, NY 13820
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
109 Stagecoach Road, Davenport, NY 13750

Closed Mar 3, 2023
$195,000
6beds
3bath
1,427sqft
29.24acres
Multi Family for Sale
109 Stagecoach Road, Davenport, NY 13750
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
109 Stagecoach Road, Davenport, NY 13750

Closed Mar 3, 2023
$195,000
3beds
1bath
1,427sqft
29.24acres
House for Sale
109 Stagecoach Road, Davenport, NY 13750
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
486 Thorn Hill Road, Colesville, NY 13813

Closed Feb 24, 2023
$680,000
3beds
2bath
3,113sqft
80.32acres
House for Sale
486 Thorn Hill Road, Colesville, NY 13813
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
5684 Turnpike Road, Meredith, NY 13753

Closed Feb 22, 2023
$590,000
4beds
3bath
2,402sqft
21.6acres
House for Sale
5684 Turnpike Road, Meredith, NY 13753
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
1340 Alameda Road, Kortright, NY 13842

Closed Feb 3, 2023
$263,000
2beds
1bath
1,161sqft
5.35acres
House for Sale
1340 Alameda Road, Kortright, NY 13842
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470
25706 State Highway 23, Harpersfield, NY 13786

Closed Jan 17, 2023
$145,000
3beds
2bath
1,159sqft
13.87acres
House for Sale
25706 State Highway 23, Harpersfield, NY 13786
Susan Muther(607) 435-0470